Mortgage fraud isn’t only a result of professional con men tricking innocent homeowners. Federal figures and criminal cases indicate that deceptive borrowers are responsible for a large part of current losses on mortgage loans.
According to a federal interagency called The Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, borrowers or customers constitute 57 percent of the subjects of Suspicious Activity Reports filed by banks and other reporting institutions. Brokers were next in line, representing 10 percent of the complaints, followed by appraisers, employees and agents.
“When borrowers are having difficulties in making payments, any fraudulent activity regarding the loan normally sticks out like a sore thumb, so many individuals and institutions are found to be participants in various types of mortgage fraud,” said Jason Boone, research assistant for the National White Collar Crime Center, in an interview.
Mortgage fraud is the fastest growing white collar crime in the U.S. The FBI estimates annual losses of $4 billion to $6 billion in mortgage-related fraud, and the numbers are expected to increase. According to the FBI, debt settlement companies, lawyers, brokers and real estate agents are among those involved in schemes of money laundering and creating fake legal documents. To obtain upfront fees, schemers create phony documents which they guarantee will satisfy struggling mortgage owners’ loan requirements.
“As properties affected by mortgage fraud are sold at artificially inflated prices, properties in surrounding neighborhoods also become artificially inflated,” stated an FBI report on mortgage fraud.
According to the FBI, the number of SARs filed for the third quarter of 2009 were 7 percent greater than in the year-earlier quarter, and a preliminary report for the full year 2009 showed an increase of 44 percent in SAR filings since the full year 2007, before the economic meltdown. In the 2009 third quarter Illinois ranked fourth in mortgage-fraud-related Suspicious Activity Reports in the U.S, with 1,441 SARs. California was first.
In 2008 federal prosecutors in Chicago charged 67 defendants with carrying out fraudulent mortgage schemes, and last June they brought similar cases against another 41 persons.
In some cases the defendants were charged with fraudulently inflating the values of dilapidated homes in urban areas. Other defendants were accused of fraudulently obtaining loans totaling than $17.2 million on expensive condominiums and penthouses in a River North building known as the Millenium Centre.
One defendent, Lawrence A. Luckett, CEO of the former Home Mortgage Inc., in Burr Ridge. Ill., allegedly submitted loan requests to GMAC Bank between August 2007 and March 2008 for more than 450 fictitious residential mortgage loans, causing the bank a loss of more than $15 million.
John Terzakis, a 52 year-old resident of Hindsdale, Ill., owner of Vesta Strategies, was arrested in January and charged with money laundering, wire fraud and stealing from clients to whom he promised real estate. He is currently in home confinement with electronic monitoring awaiting trial.
“Mortgage fraud is a serious issue that affects not just financial institutions but ordinary citizens who may have invested in such financial institutions,” stated Patrick J. Fitzgerald, U.S. attorney for the Northern District of Illinois, in the FBI report.
In other Midwest federal cases, Beverly A. Ross, of Noblesville, Ind., was sentenced to 63 months in federal prison following her guilty plea for fraudulently obtaining loans on 34 properties, causing several lenders a loss of $5.6 million.
Last month Debbie Sferrazza of Westchester, Ohio was indicted along with five members of her family for allegedly using her mortgage lending companies to submit loan applications using false employment documents and Social Security numbers, among other things. According to another federal indictment, handed up Feb. 10, Jeremy Beadle, a mortgage broker, bought five properties in St. Louis for $32,000, obtained false appraisals of them and sold them to people who qualified for mortgages based on false loan applications.
“Over the course of the next year or two, I expect mortgage fraud numbers to remain high, if not increase since the economy will most likely still be on shaky grounds,” said Boone of the National White Collar Crime Center.
According to the federal interagency report, lenders’ Suspicious Activity Reports of SARs reported foreclosure and loan modification fraud as common, evidenced by occupancy misrepresentation, Social Security number discrepancies, and altered or forged documentation.
“SARs involving loan modifications described potential fraud in either the application for the loan modification, or in the older loan which came under review subsequent to the modification application,” the report stated.
Thirty-five percent of the SARs indicated an amount ranging from $100,000 to $250,000, while 5 percent were filed for suspected amounts of $1 million or more.
The other side of mortgage fraud is evidenced by complaints from homebuyers, which are also rising. Illinois Attorney General Lisa Madigan’s office reports that nearly 4,000 homeowners filed residential mortgage complaints last year, a 65 percent increase over 2008.
“Hardworking people are struggling to make their mortgage payments on time. They’re fighting to cope with mounting debt, and they’re being targeted by con artists looking to make a quick buck,” Madigan stated in a press release.
In October 2008 she sued Countrywide, the nation’s largest mortgage lender, on charges of predatory lending and obtained an $8.7 billion settlement.
This month Madigan sued four “debt settlement companies” alleging that they engaged in deceptive marketing practices, charging excessive fees and not changing their customer’s debt situation.
“These companies are unfairly luring financially strapped consumers with misleading claims that they can effectively eliminate consumer’s debt,” Madigan stated in a release.
Last year Madigan filed 31 lawsuits targeting mortgage rescue scams.