Real Estate Fraud and Hollywood
Last Friday, the Los Angeles Times today ran a story entitled “Brokers to Westside elite accused of fraud,” in which staff writers Annette Haddad and Diane Wedner reported the previous day’s indictment of two “high-profile Beverly Hills real estate agents and two licensed appraisers” on multiple charges of conspiracy, bank fraud and loan fraud (another term for mortgage fraud). The quartet stand accused of conspiring to dupe lenders out “more than $40 million in fraudulent loans for homes in some of Southern California’s most expensive neighborhoods.”
Named in the indictment are Joseph Babajian and Kyle Grasso, agents with Prudential California Realty, and appraisers Lila Rizk of Trabuco Canyon and Scott Robinson of Dana Point. Babajian and Grasso were also charged with money laundering.
Although those charged are certainly innocent until proven guilty, this case draws attention to the growing problem of real estate fraud and mortgage fraud and the threat that fraud poses to the real estate industry and homeowners, as well. As I explain in my most recent book, co-author of the recent book Protect Yourself from Real Estate and Mortgage Fraud: Preserving the American Dream of Homeownership:
Most people consider mortgage fraud to be a victimless crime, but that is far from the truth. The way this type of mortgage fraud typically works is that the buyer obtains an inflated appraisal making the home appear to be worth more than it really is, so the lender will loan them more money. At closing, the buyer gets the extra money back. Some people think that there is nothing wrong with this practice. After all, the buyer must make payments on a larger mortgage, the agent receives a bigger commission, and housing values in the area tend to rise. On the surface and in the short term, it appears that everybody wins.
As my co-author Rachel Dollar and I go on to explain, however, this sort of logic simply rationalizes the very real crime of mortgage fraud. Artificially inflated appraisals and mortgage fraud eventually result in inflated housing prices, higher loan default rates, increasing rates of foreclosures, higher property taxes, and the erosion of neighborhoods.
Cash back at closing schemes, like those described in the L.A. Times story, are designed to intentionally fool a lender into approving a loan that’s higher than what they would normally have approved if they had all the facts. As I have pointed here on FlippingFrenzy.com before, every 1003 (Uniform Residential Loan Application) has a statement you have to sign claiming that the information on the form is correct to the best of your knowledge. If you sign a form that contains false information, you are guilty of committing a felony, regardless of what you decide to use that money for.
We should all be committed to getting the word out about real estate and mortgage fraud, so consumers as well as industry insiders (who happen to be involved in more than 80 percent of the cases involving mortgage fraud) will have no question of what is right and what is wrong. We ned to provide consumers and professionals with the information and tools they need to spot the signs of fraud, stop it in its tracks, and report it to the proper authorities. Only by creating a army of fraud busters can we hope to turn the tide and preserve the American Dream of Homeownership.


