California REALTOR® Jose Oliva Sentenced for Real Estate Fraud: A real estate agent from Fontana, Calif., who was arrested in July of this year on felony charges connected to real estate fraud, has finally been sentenced… to six (6) months in jail followed by three (3) years probation.

John Matouk pleads guilty in Michigan of quitclaim deed fraud: According to the Wayne County Prosecutor’s Office, in February 2004, Matouk, who owned half a property in the 1100 block of Telegraph in Dearborn, forged a quitclaim deed from an elderly couple that transferred the entire property to his company, LM Investments of Dearborn LLC. Before his sentencing last week, Matouk was ordered to pay $26,000 in real estate taxes, the outstanding balance on a $650,000 loan, and court and probation costs. Because of his plea, Matouk received a sentence of two (2) years’ probation.

Rockland County, New York, task force targets mortgage fraud: Rockland County, NY, officials are trying to fight the worsening mortgage fraud problem by forming a Real Estate Fraud Investigation Task Force. The task force, a joint effort of Rockland District Attorney, County Clerk and County Sheriff, will investigate and prosecute cases involving recorded real estate documents, with an emphasis on instances in which the victim’s home is at risk of foreclosure.

U.S. Attorney charges Missouri mortgage brokers with cash-back-at-closing fraud: John F. Wood, United States Attorney for the Western District of Missouri, announced that several mortgage brokers are among six Missouri residents indicted by a federal grand jury last week for participating in several related mortgage fraud schemes. Charles M. Davis, 34, of Rogersville, Mo., Cheryl Joan Kassebaum, 42, and her husband, Scott Allen Kassebaum, 42, both of Ozark, Mo., Randall Lee Hall, 59, and Shanda Lynn Moore, 44, both of Springfield, Mo., and Steven Ray Spencer, 47, of Carl Junction, Mo., were charged in a 55-count indictment returned by a federal grand jury in Springfield. Davis, a former mortgage broker, was the owner of Master Marketing Consultants. The Kassebaums, former mortgage brokers, were owners of Metro Consulting Group. Hall is a former mortgage broker.

Westport, Connecticut, mortgage broker Fred Stevens pleads guilty to mortgage fraud: Stevens, 53, of Easton, Conn., is charged with submitting fraudulent mortgage applications with IndyMac Bank and other financial institutions resulting in losses of over $1,000,000.

Florida real estate appraiser Juan Gonzalez guilty of mortgage fraud: Gonzalez fraudulently obtained loans on more than 40 properties, victimizing numerous lenders and grossing over $5,000,000 in the process. As a result, the 51-year-old will spend the next 30 years in federal prison and pay a $1 million fine.

The U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Eastern District of Michigan has finally created a multiagency task force to deal with real estate and mortgage fraud in eastern Michigan. As mortgage fraud continues to have significant consequences that affect the housing market, law enforcement in Michigan has decided now is the time to formally step up its commitment to fighting what for the last three years has been the fastest-growing white collar crime in America.

Participating agencies and financial institutions include:

• Bank of America
• Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI)
• Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. – Inspector General Office
• Flagstar Bank
• Internal Revenue Service
• JP Morgan Chase Bank
• Oakland County Register of Deeds
• Small Business Administration- Office of Inspector General
• State of Michigan Attorney General’s Office
• State of Michigan Office of Financial Regulation
• U.S. Department of Agriculture- Office of Inspector General
• U.S. Dept. of Housing & Urban Dev. – Office Inspector General
• U.S. Trustee Program
• United States Postal Inspection Service
• Washtenaw County Clerk/Register of Deeds
• Wayne County Register of Deeds – Deed Fraud Unit
• Wayne County Sheriff’s Department
• Wayne County Prosecuting Attorney

The acting U.S. Attorney for the District, Terrence Berg, issued a press release stating:

“I want to commend the leadership of the FBI in Detroit for taking the initiative on this project, and also recognize the participation of our private sector partners. I am very encouraged by the commitment of the Task Force members.“

Rather than congratulating themselves for the task force’s formation, as Berg does above, perhaps the U.S. Attorney’s office for the Eastern District of Michigan — along with the other agencies and the banks involved in this new effort — should apologize to the residents of Michigan for taking this long to act in a coordinated way.

As Flipping Frenzy has relentlessly reported over the years, Michigan’s real estate and mortgage fraud woes are legendary. In August of this year, the Mortgage Asset Research Institute (MARI) reported Michigan ranked 3rd in the nation for loans containing alleged fraud or serious material misrepresentation (and just in case you’re wondering, MARI ranked the state #12 in 2001, #8 in 2003, and #5 in 2004). For its part, the FBI’s most recent index of the worst states for mortgage fraud puts Michigan in the slot: #3.

Recognizing that roughly 90% of all reported real estate and mortgage fraud losses involve collaboration or collusion by real estate industry insiders, the Mulit-Agency Mortgage Fraud Task Force will concentrate their efforts on fraud for profit, which everyone knows by now involves the skimming of equity, falsely inflating the value of the property through false appraisals, and the issuance of loans on fictitious properties.

To report real estate and mortgage fraud in Detroit or anywhere in Michigan, Flipping Frenzy readers can call the Detroit Metro Mortgage Fraud Hotline at (313) 237-4530, or contact the Wayne County Register of Deeds’ Deed Fraud Hotline at (313) 224-5869.

Forged and counterfeit documents commonly play a role in real estate and mortgage fraud, and notaries form a front line of defense in these areas. With that in mind, the following email message arrived yesterday afternoon, and since it is categorized as an alert, I feel it is worth sharing here:

DATE: September 11, 2008
FROM: Tim Reiniger, Executive Director
TO: Concerned Notaries of Michigan
RE: Your Support Needed For Important Fraud-Fighting Legislation

As a Notary in a state where there is no record-keeping requirement, you know the importance of keeping Notary records. The FBI and law enforcement agencies across the nation have cited Notary records as vital evidence in the investigation and prosecution of mortgage fraud and identity theft crimes. Despite the downturn in the mortgage industry, mortgage fraud has actually risen. In fact, the Mortgage Asset Research Institute has ranked Michigan number three in the nation in mortgage fraud for the first quarter of 2008. Because you use a Notary journal, we are asking for your support of important fraud-fighting legislation currently pending in the state Legislature. Officially designated as HB 5448 (with similar companion bills HB 5379 and 5431), this bill would require Notaries in Michigan to keep a record of all their official acts to facilitate prosecution of identity thieves.

ACTION ITEM: Please contact your State Representative and urge this legislator to support HB 5448.

For information on finding and contacting your State Representative click here: http://house.michigan.gov/find_a_rep.asp

Curious about House Bill 5448, I visited the Michigan Legislature’s website. There, I found the entire Michigan Notary Public Act along with the proposed language referenced in Tim Reiniger’s email alert:

A NOTARY PUBLIC SHALL KEEP, MAINTAIN, AND PROTECT, UNDER HIS OR HER EXCLUSIVE CONTROL, A CHRONOLOGICAL PAPER OR ELECTRONIC OFFICIAL JOURNAL OF NOTARIAL ACTS. THE JOURNAL SHALL CONTAIN THE FOLLOWING ENTRIES FOR EACH NOTARIAL ACT:

(A) THE DATE AND TIME OF THE NOTARIAL ACT.

(B) THE TYPE OF NOTARIAL ACT.

(C) THE TYPE, TITLE, OR DESCRIPTION AND DATE OF EVERY RECORD NOTARIZED.

(D) THE NAME, ADDRESS, SIGNATURE, AND, IN THE CASE OF REAL ESTATE RECORDS, THE RIGHT THUMBPRINT OF EACH PERSON WHOSE SIGNATURE IS NOTARIZED.

According to the National Notary Association (NNA), each year, countless civil and criminal court challenges are made to documents after they have been legally notarized. Claims of fraud, forgery, coercion and other misdeeds, real or not, are common. In some cases, an original document’s loss or theft makes the issue even more difficult to resolve.

A Notary’s journal, says the NNA, can prevent the frauds and many of the baseless lawsuits that burden our courts as well as safeguard personal rights when a valuable document is lost or fraudulently altered. The NNA also says the Notary’s journal supplies independent physical evidence that a particular document was signed or acknowledged on a specific day by a person who was positively identified by a Notary. Other benefits of the Notary’s journal (again, from NNA):

• It deters forgers and impostors who are naturally unwilling to leave a signature (and a thumbprint) that would incriminate them.
• A Notary journal protects the signer and other involved parties in the event the document is lost, challenged or fraudulently altered.
• It protects the Notary from baseless allegations by showing reasonable care was exercised in identifying the signer and performing the notarial act.
• A Notary journal provides critical evidence to law enforcement authorities in prosecuting frauds.
• It discourages groundless lawsuits by showing that a signer appeared before the Notary and was properly identified.
• A Notary journal can avert or quickly resolve litigation, helping unclog our over-burdened courts.

As I point in my book “Protect Yourself from Real Estate & Mortgage Fraud: Preserving the American Dream of Homeownership,” given the right to notarize documents is a privilege that’s not to be taken lightly. To make notarization of documents less susceptible to abuse, in addition to what has been proposed for Michigan, I recommend the following:

• Requirements for becoming a Notary should be much stricter. In some areas, becoming a Notary is easier than getting a cash advance at an ATM.
• Notaries should have an electronic system that captures the signer’s information (thumbprint and driver’s license) and verifies the information.
• Notaries should be required to pass a fraud-certification exam.
• A notary’s thumbprint should be included on the notarized document or within the seal. (Notaries often claim that they are the victims of identity theft. Requiring a thumbprint would help prevent that from occurring.)
• Notaries should receive newsletters in print or electronically keeping them informed of their responsibilities and any new fraud schemes that may exploit the powers of a notary.
• Notaries should be legally prohibited from notarizing real estate or loan documents for family members.
• Notaries should be legally prohibited from notarizing documents in transactions in which they have a direct or indirect beneficial interest. (Some states prohibit Notaries from notarizing documents in transactions in which the notary has a direct interest but provide no wording dealing with indirect interests.)
• An additional witness should be required to verify the identity and signatures of those signing the documents and then sign as a witness.
• Notaries should be required to obtain the thumbprint of the signatory in all transactions involving real property.
• Notaries should be provided with the legal discretion to refuse to notarize a document if the Notary believes that the signer is under duress or the victim of fraud.
• As is proposed in Michigan, all states should mandate that notorial logs be maintained.

Con artists will always find ways to exploit vulnerabilities in the system, but the system can and must fight back.

Reported incidents of mortgage fraud in the U.S. increased by nearly 50% in the first quarter of 2008 from a year ago, according to a new report released this week. The report is based on data submitted by Mortgage Asset Research Institute (MARISM) subscribers about loans that were originated in the first quarter of this year and have since been classified as fraudulent, and shows a whopping 42% increase in filings. At the local level, Florida continues to lead all states in reported mortgage fraud. In fact, according to the report, Florida accounted for 24% of all properties with material misrepresentation for loans originated during the first quarter of 2008, and the Miami MSA alone boasts 49% of all of the reports submitted for properties in the state.

California ranked second in the first quarter of this year (with 52% of the properties with misrepresentation coming from the Los Angeles area), followed by a three-way tie for third place among Illinois, Maryland and Michigan.

Major urban areas also score the highest in Illinois, Maryland and Michigan. Ninety-four percent of investigations in the state of Illinois are for properties in the Chicago MSA, while in Maryland, 25% of reports are in the Baltimore MSA. In addition, the Detroit MSA counts for 56% of all of the misrepresentation reported for Michigan.

For all states, the most common type of fraud was in the “General Application Misrepresentation” category, followed closely by misrepresentations related to income and employment. In addition, multiple types of fraud types–such as identity theft and identity fraud–continue to appear in a significant percentage of loan transactions.

The report–which available for download here–presents a number of interesting and noteworthy trends:

• In general, misrepresentation on the mortgage application trends high in each of the states.
• Income and employment misrepresentation on the mortgage application rank high in Florida,
  California, Illinois and Maryland. Florida and Maryland report higher income than employment misrepresentation, and California and Illinois report slightly higher employment than income misrepresentation.
• Michigan shows a high percentage of asset and debt misrepresentation on the mortgage application.
• Appraisal misrepresentation (including value inflation and incorrect use of comparables) is most prevalent in Michigan.
• Maryland has an abnormally high percentage — 69% — of tax return and financial statement misrepresentation.

In its final analysis, this week’s report concludes the following:

1. The first quarter data reveals that loan application misrepresentation continues to plague the industry. According to the FBI’s 2007 Mortgage Fraud Report, “the downward trend in the housing market provides an ideal climate for mortgage fraud perpetrators to employ a myriad of schemes suitable to a down market.” Simply stated, mortgage fraud will not disappear — in fact, it is expected to significantly grow, evolve and penetrate new areas within the industry.
2. As the nation’s lenders redraw their credit practices, we see a continued need to highlight and eliminate loans that are not in good order at the point of origination, well before prefunding processors spend any effort to seek added verification or validation of the mortgage application information. If loan applications are not in good order when submitted, the loan data may likely be adjusted to fit the business practice expectation to meet the requirements for funding, which ultimately may result in funded loans that quickly go bad.
3. To save itself from schemes both commonplace and new, the mortgage industry must continue to strengthen its attention to and practice of due diligence to ensure that transactions are in good order at the point of origination. This includes an analysis of the borrower’s identity, as well as the players involved in each of the real estate roles whether they are outsourced or work directly for the lender.
4. As lenders pursue higher-quality loans for the market, the priority should be on identifying poor quality at the earliest possible point in the process — and at the lowest possible cost. In MARI’s view, the origination and prefunding processes offer the largest and least expensive opportunities to assure funding of higher quality loans. How a lender accepts or rejects a loan application at the front door is often all a criminal needs to see how much further he or she may push through the loan process.
5. Pre-funding fraud detection solutions can help prevent the risk of application discrepancies, exposure to compromised identities and establishment of relationships with insiders who leverage someone’s good name to perpetrate fraud. If on the mortgage application general misrepresentation or income, appraiser or employer misrepresentation were checked adequately at origination and pre-funding, in this quarter’s examples, would there still be significant fraud to report…?
6. Mortgage fraud inflicts damage to profits, reputations and consumer confidence. Today, it is wise to ensure you know the customers, employees and vendors involved in every loan transaction — doing this early in the process can result in overall protection from tainted pipelines and hidden threats to loan quality.

We have all heard that if an offer sounds too good to be true, it probably is too good to be true. But what if the offer comes from a high profile member of your own community… say it comes from a professional athlete who spent years helping the local NBA team make it to the playoffs and into championship games. Surely, someone as well known as a National Basketball Association player wouldn’t involve himself as a ringleader in real estate fraud scam, would he?

This is the question I encountered recently when Bruce McClellan and his attorney Mike J. Smith contacted my office for information on where to turn for help in an alleged mortgage fraud scam perpetrated by veteran Detroit Pistons basketball player Lindsey Hunter.

Here is what happened, in Bruce McClellan’s own words (provided as an exclusive to FlippingFrenzy.com):

My name is Bruce McClellan (picture left) and this is my account of what happened between myself and NBA player Lindsey Hunter, and Hunter’s real estate investment firm, L&I Enterprises, LLC, and L&I’s other business personnel—Ivan “Iron” Johnson and Denna P. Tansil. I met Lindsey Hunter through his business associate, Ivan “Iron” Johnson, who I originally met years earlier at the Pontiac School system where I work as a boiler engineer.

In February of 2007, Ivan Johnson approached me to see if I would be interested in investing in real estate. According to Ivan, he had just opened a real estate investment firm with Detroit Pistons’ basketball player Lindsey Hunter, and if Lindsey felt they had a deal that I just had to look at, he wanted to know if I’d be interested.

When I asked him to tell me more about this business he was involved in with Lindsey Hunter, Ivan said they had formed a company called L&I Enterprises, LLC, for the purpose of buying and selling homes for a profit. After he swore to me that his business with Lindsey Hunter was 100% legit, I said yes to learning more about real estate investment opportunities.

A few weeks later, Ivan Johnson told me that he and Lindsay Hunter (picture right) had a real estate opportunity that would make me a lot of money. Ivan asked me to meet with himself and Lindsay at L&I Enterprises’ office for the purpose of checking my credit and running a background check on me to ensure that I’d qualify for a loan. When I arrived at their office, Lindsey he had left already, so Ivan handled the request for my credit report all on his own. Once he saw the results, Ivan said I had a great credit score (it was in the neighborhood of 790), and I was told I’d soon be a millionaire from investing in real estate.

At about the end of February, I heard from Ivan Johnson again. This time he said that he and Lindsey Hunter found the perfect property for me to invest in, and that once the deal was finalized, I’d earn $300,000 for my participation. According to Lindsay Hunter and Ivan Johnson, the deal involved buying a $1.2 Million home and selling it for $2.1 Million to a buyer Lindsey and Ivan had already identified and received a commitment from to buy the house. All I needed to do, Ivan and Lindsey told me, was apply for the home loan for the $1.2 Million purchase, and they’d handle the rest.

When I expressed doubt about my ability to qualify for a $1.2 Million loan, both men told me not to worry, that they would handle everything. Once again, as I did when Ivan first told me about Lindsey Hunter and L&I Enterprises, I expressed my concern for only working on legitimate deals and keeping my good credit in good standing. Again, both men told me I had nothing to be concerned about.

For a man making less than $45,000 a year, what Lindsay Hunter was telling me was quite appealing, as was the star treatment I was receiving from a well-known veteran NBA player.

On March 30, 2007, Ivan Johnson called to tell me that he needed me to meet him at LaSalle Bank in Farmington Hills, MI, where it was necessary for me to add my name to Lindsey and Ivy (wife) Hunter’s bank account. When I asked why my name was being added to Lindsey’s account, Ivan told me that this was necessary so it appeared to the bank that I had more money than I really did, which would help me qualify for the loan. When I asked Ivan why Lindsey wasn’t worried about adding me to his personal account, Ivan told me that Lindsey knew that I was an honest person and that I would never attempt to steal from him (which of course was true—I would never steal money from anyone).

Ivan Johnson and I went to the bank together where Ivan called Lindsay Hunter on his phone. Lindsey spoke to LaSalle Bank employee Shatha Atcho-Salmu, and from what I could hear of the conversation, it was obvious that they knew each other. Anyway, with the assistance of LaSalle Bank’s Shatha Atchoo-Salmu, and without Lindsey Hunter or his wife Ivy Hunter present, I signed my name onto Lindsey and Ivy’s account, which I was told Lindsey had authorized.

On April 30, 2007, Ivan Johnson called to tell me that we got the house (1718 Morningside Way, Bloomfield Hills, MI 48302 — pictured below) and that I needed to meet him to sign all the necessary paperwork. We met at Prudential Cranbrook Real Estate office on Franklin Road in Franklin, MI, to sign the papers. When I arrived I asked if Lindsey would be there and Ivan told me no, Lindsey had a game. I told Ivan that I would be taking his lead because I did not understand the paperwork and Ivan said that was fine. There were about four or five other people there including the sellers of the property.

Luckily, Denna P. Tansil—a realtor from L&I Enterprises, LLC—was there to guide us through the paperwork, which did not include any reference to me receiving $300,000 once the other sale had gone through. When I pointed this out to Denna, she wrote the following into the contract: “Seller will receive no less than $300,000.00 at the sale of the property.” I showed Ivan what Denna wrote, and after he checked over, he said everything was fine and Denna signed the paper and gave me a copy.

After about two months had passed, I asked Ivan Johnson if he could give me a full tour of the house and property. At first, he agreed but on the day we were to meet, Ivan was too busy. So I didn’t try again until much later because I really was not concerned since both Ivan and Lindsey Hunter had told me that they had a buyer for the house and it was basically on its way to being sold.

Later, I told Ivan that I needed to talk to Lindsay Hunter myself because the house had not sold like he said it would and I did not like the way things were going. Ivan called Lindsey while I was there and Lindsey told Ivan to tell me that for sure nothing was wrong. Regardless, I said that I needed to talk to him.

A few days later, Ivan called and told me that Lindsey had invited me to a Detriot Pistons home basketball game for the day of October 24, 2007. After being treated like a VIP in a private suite during the game, Lindsey, Ivan and I went to an upscale restaurant in Bloomfield Hills (MI), where Lindsey proceeded to tell me that everything for the real estate investment deal was in great shape—he reconfirmed that they had a buyer lined up and ready to buy the house from us for $2.1 Million—and that he wasn’t going to do me wrong or get me involved in any illegal activities. Lindsey even went as far as to tell me that he was financially set for the rest of his life, he wanted to make me and Ivan millionaires within the next one to two years, and that he wanted to make me a partner in L&I Enterprises, LLC.

When more time passed by without the house selling, I again became anxious and decided to visit the house myself. When I arrived at the house, I was surprised to find Lindsay Hunter’s truck parked in the driveway. Not knowing why his truck was there, and not seeing a way to gain access to the house, I called Ivan to get a feel for what was going on. It was then that I learned from Ivan that Lindsey and his wife Ivy were going through a rough patch—Ivan said they had separated—and that Lindsey was actually living in the house. Basically, Ivan told me that I shouldn’t go into the house right now because it might be “awkward.”

Understanding that this happens to some people, and keeping in mind Lindsey and Ivan’s previous statements about there already being a buyer for the house—which would yield $300,000 for my part of the investment—I was okay with the situation as explained to me by Ivan, and I went home. From my way of thinking, it was really Lindsey Hunter’s house anyway, and since he already had a buyer lined up and the mortgage was being paid on time—or so I assumed—there really wasn’t anything for me to worry about.

Eventually, in February of 2008, I did end up gaining access to the house, at which time I called Ivan Johnson and told him that I did not think the house was worth $1.2 Million.

In April 2008, I received a phone call from Countrywide inquiring about the mortgage payments. Apparently, the mortgage on the house had not been paid in quite some time, and Countrywide was calling me to demand payment.

Immediately after I got off the phone with Countrywide, I called Ivan Johnson to see just what in the heck was going on. Ivan informed me at that time—and for the first time ever—that Lindsey Hunter had shut down L&I Enterprises, and that in doing so, he had left a lot of people “holdin’ the bag” and that we were on our own. Lindsey, it seems, had gone home to his wife.

I asked Ivan how I was supposed to pay an $8,700 monthly note on my salary, to which he told that what Lindsey Hunter did was wrong and that he would talk with Lindsey to see if Lindsey would make things right for me. Rather than wait for Lindsey to call Ivan, Ivan tried calling Lindsey several times but discovered that Lindsey had changed his phone numbers; he was impossible to reach.

Finally, around the end of May of 2008, Ivan Johnson and Lindsey Hunter called me on a three-way call and asked: “What do you think you deserve to get you out of this house?” I told them that since my credit was ruined from the lack of mortgage payments, I wanted $50,000 and for them to get caught up on all of the outstanding monies owed to Countrywide. At this point, Lindsey became very angry and started cursing at me over and over. I told Lindsey that I was not cursing at him and I did not understand why he was cursing at me. I told Ivan that I didn’t want to talk under these conditions any more and I hung up. Ivan called me back about twenty minutes later and he said that what Lindsey had done was wrong.

About another week passed and Ivan and Lindsey called me again for a three-way conversation. “Bruce, this is Ivan and Lindsey is on the phone,” Ivan said. I said ok and Lindsey said hello and then proceeded to tell me that he was going to do whatever it took to get me out of the deal. He would restore my credit, get me off the house, and give me $25,000.

Since I just wanted my name off the deal, I agreed. The $25,000 was much less than the $300,000 I was originally told I would receive for investing in the house, but like I said, I just wanted to get free of the whole mess.

I never heard from Lindsay Hunter again.

Long story short, Lindsay Hunter never paid the $25,000 he promised me, my credit is ruined, and come to find out that back in April—when I signed all those closing documents Ivan Johnson and Denna Tansil told me to sign—I unknowingly signed for two loans, not just one!

Now I have legal representation and am hoping that because of this story on FlippingFrenzy.com and Lindsey Hunter’s profile, someone with judicial authority will listen and Hunter, Ivan Johnson, and Denna Tansil will be held accountable for what they’ve done.

~ Bruce McClellan

Thank you, Bruce, for sharing your account of what happened between yourself and Lindsey Hunter and Hunter’s business partners, Ivan Johnson and Denna Tansil. This story involves many of the trademark signatures of real estate and mortgage fraud:

• Bruce was a naïve borrower with nearly perfect credit. He had no idea a scam was taking place right under his nose, which ultimately made him the perfect straw buyer.
• This particular case features a long-term relationship—between Bruce and Ivan— making it easy for Bruce to be conned. Ivan knew that Bruce would jump at the chance to make serious money, and he knew that Bruce was a trusting soul with nearly perfect credit.
• What scam wouldn’t be complete without a glamour player (i.e., a ring leader). In this case, it is a professional basketball player claiming to want to take a common man under his wing and make him a millionaire. In other cases it is the smooth talking, good looking, get the deal done, likeable person. In either case, Lindsay Hunter seems to fit the bill.
• This scam involves fabricating income and/or assets, which is one of the oldest tricks in the book. Lindsay Hunter added Bruce McClellan to his million dollar bank account to boost Bruce’s ability to qualify for a loan.
• Bruce was promised easy money and no risk for his involvement in what he was told was a legitimate real estate deal. How many times have we heard that one!

A common thread running through most real estate fraud schemes is an offer that is to good to be true. When prominent public figures like Lindsay Hunter make offers that seem too good to be true, especially in harsh economic times, consumers tend to lose their judgment and make poor decisions

As a result of Bruce coming forward, I was able to put his case in front of serious law enforcement officials who are now attempting to sort through this mess. From Crain’s Detroit Business:

Is Lindsey Hunter, the veteran guard of the Detroit Pistons, a victim of mortgage fraud? Or is he a perpetrator?

That’s what two investigations, one by the Wayne County Register of Deeds’ mortgage-fraud task force, the other by the FBI, want to determine.

So far, Wayne County investigators consider him a victim, with someone else serving as what they describe as “a mastermind.” The FBI, on the other hand, according to sources close to its investigation, has him as its main focus and as a leading participant in at least two possibly fraudulent deals that went awry.

Stay turned to FlippingFrenzy.com for more information and developments on this story. In the meantime, read “Pistons guard: Duplicitous or dupe in mortgage fraud?” for more information.

A federal grand jury in Michigan has indicted four men–including a mortgage broker and an appraiser–for allegedly running a $1.9 million real estate/mortgage fraud scheme. Hassan Nagi, 30, of Dearborn Heights, Michigan; Ali Haidous, 24, of Dearborn; Safi Bzeih, 35, of Dearborn; and Hussein Aoun, 23, of Dearborn Heights reportedly conspired to secure fraudulent mortgages from Countrywide Bank, Washington Mutual, Fifth Third Bank, IndyMac Federal Bank, Net Bank, and Sun Trust for more than 15 properties between April 2005 and April 2008.

The indictment alleges that Hassan Nagi worked as a mortgage broker and was responsible for submitting false and fraudulent applications to obtain the mortgages. Ali Haidous was a real estate appraiser who provided fraudulent appraisals for the properties. Bzeih and Aoun recruited sellers and straw buyers for the properties.

According to the indictment, after the Nagi and Haidous identified a willing seller of a property, Nagi secured financing for a straw buyer. False income and employment information was provided to the lender using fraudulent W-2 forms. In support of each loan, Nagi also submitted an inflated appraisal, created by Haidous.

After the inflated mortgage was funded at closing, the seller received sufficient funds to pay off any existing mortgage as well as a bonus for participating in the real estate fraud scheme. The remainder of the proceeds from the inflated mortgage were shared between Hassan Nagi, Ali Haidous and one of the straw buyers.

Nagi, Haidous, and Bzeih were expected to appear in federal court before Magistrate Judge Virginia Morgan yesterday afternoon, for their initial appearances and arraignment on the indictment. Hussein Aoun is a fugitive in Lebanon. The case is being prosecuted by Assistant U.S. Attorney Leonid Feller.

According to the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), which earlier today issued yet another Mortgage Fraud Advisory, here are the latest Real Estate Fraud statistics:

• Estimated Annual Losses: $4 billion to $6 billion
• Total Mortgage Fraud Suspicious Activity Reports in Fiscal Year 2007: 46,717, with $813 million in losses
• Total FBI Mortgage Fraud Task Forces/Working Groups (June 2008): 42
• Pending FBI Mortgage Fraud Investigations (May 2008): 1,380
• Cases opened in Fiscal Year 2007: 462 (compared to 295 in Fiscal Year 2003)
• Successes in Fiscal Year 2007: 321 indictments/informations; 260 convictions
• States with Significant Mortgage Fraud problems in 2008:

1. Florida
2. Nevada
3. Michigan
4. California
5. Utah
6. Georgia
7. Virginia
8. Illinois
9. New York
10. Minnesota

Predatory lenders employ many of the same illegal tactics found in other write-ups here on Flipping Frenzy. Loan officers, for example, may obtain inflated appraisals to get the homeowner a higher loan or will falsify income information to qualify the borrower for a mortgage.

Rather than doing those things to help the borrower, predatory lenders are simply out for themselves. Their actions rarely have any tangible benefits for borrowers and often saddle homeowners with loans they cannot afford. Loan officers—as you’re about to read—sometimes simply use borrowers to engage in a type of fraud I like to refer to as fraud for commissions.

Recently, one Flipping Frenzy reader came forward to share her experience with predatory lending and fraud for commission.

My name is Kim Sikorski, and in 2000 I was living in a one-bedroom apartment in New Baltimore, Michigan, when a local builder began construction on the Aspen Glen Condominiums right outside my front door. I remember thinking to myself how nice they looked and wished that someday I could own a home like that. Fast forward three years and I did.

To be honest, I wasn’t sure I could buy anything. I made ok money for a single person but I wasn’t sure it’d be enough to actually buy a home. To get the process started, I went to talk to a man named Dave Piccinini at Lira Financial in Clinton Township., MI (David Piccinini Inc. dba Lira Financial; 16600 18 Mile Rd.; Clinton Township., Michigan 48038). He was a friend of my boss, Ralph Bianchi, so I thought that I would be able to trust him.

I told Mr. Piccinini where I was looking to live and gave him the information he needed to check my credit report and get things started. A few weeks later I received a call from Stephen Tyree, the Lira Financial loan officer assigned to my application. Mr. Tyree called to tell me that my credit was good and I qualified to purchase one of the Aspen Glen condos with a mortgage at 6 ¼% (which for me translated into a monthly of $912.00). Before long, I went ahead and signed the purchase agreement and then started picking out carpet, countertops, tile color, etc. From my perspective, I was in the process of living the American dream of home ownership; I was buying my own home and I couldn’t be happier.

On August 27, 2003, I closed on my condo at the Mt. Clemens MI, office of Greco Title Co. To my surprise, neither Stephen Tyree or Dave Piccinini were present. It was there–at the closing–that I first found out that I was placed into an adjustable rate mortgage (ARM) that was only fixed for two years.

At the time, I only had a few days left to move out of my apartment, so I went ahead and signed all the documents and looked forward to moving into my new home. For me, the closing was a exciting day in my life. My mom and sister were even there by my side, taking pictures along the way.

The next day I talked to Dave Piccinini at Lira Financial and asked about the adjustable rate mortgage without escrow. Mr. Piccinini told me not to worry because in two years we would refinance and be able to set up escrow for my property taxes (which, by the way, were not included the first time). Eventually, I started having trouble keeping up with the taxes, and once again talked to Dave Piccinini about the situation. As he did before, Mr. Piccinini told me not to worry, that the taxing authority couldn’t do anything about it until I was four tax bills behind, and that by then we will have refinanced and paid off the back taxes, and set up escrow before that happens.

Based on Dave Piccinini’s recommendation, I went ahead as planned. About a week or so before I was supposed to close, my mortgage company at the time, Homecomings Financial, paid the back taxes (to protect their interest) and put me into forced placed escrow, which added to my principle and interest payment. My monthly payment went from $912 to $1,280 overnight.

When I called Dave Piccinini at Lira Financial, to tell him what happened, he told me this wasn’t a problem because we would just add it to the new mortgage. Just before closing I went to Mr. Piccinini’s office where I learned for the first time that he had placed me into a interest-only mortgage. I was told that my new mortgage was at 8%, 30-year fixed interest. I immediately told the staff in Mr. Piccinini’s Lira Financial office to stop all paperwork and please have Dave Piccinini call me himself as I was not aware of the interest-only loan (just like I was not aware that I was placed in an adjustable rate mortgage the first time around).

Long story short, I never heard from Dave Piccinini until he called about six months later to tell me that I owed him $350.00 for the appraisal done on my condo. I told him I was not paying him for the appraisal because I did not close with him, and we have not spoken since.

So my interest rate went up and I paid the difference for a year, but with my rate to go up a point or so a year with a ceiling of 12 ½ %, I knew I could not keep it up, so I went to see Stephen Tyree (my original loan officer at Lira Financial) who was now with Keystone Mortgage in Shelby Township, Michigan (45679 Village Blvd, Shelby Township, Michigan 48315). While it’s true that I originally knew Stephen from my association with Dave Piccinini, Stephen had refinanced my girlfriend’s mortgage and she was very happy with the results. I told Stephen the situation I was in—which he was well aware of�