Stephen Thomas Bybel had a business idea that would make him a landlord and line his pockets while sprucing up neighborhoods where homes in foreclosure were left to deteriorate and become targets of vandals.
Pasco County sheriff’s officials see it another way: He broke into vacant homes, changed the locks and rented out other people’s houses. Bybel was arrested at his house Wednesday and was charged with one count of scheming to defraud.
Reached by telephone after his release from jail, the 48-year-old Bybel maintained he didn’t defraud anyone.
“I think I’m doing a service to the community.”
In all, Sheriff Bob White said, Bybel took possession of 72 homes – in the Land O’ Lakes and Wesley Chapel areas — beginning in December and rented out 31 of them. White said Bybel collected nearly $17,000 for rent in January on the homes; Bybel said that’s not correct because some people didn’t pay their rent. He didn’t say how much he collected.
Ken Londo said he gave Bybel $650 for a three-bedroom house in Land O’ Lakes two weeks ago.
“I had no idea, actually,” he said when told of the allegations against Bybel.
“I’m freaking out. What are you going to do?” said his wife, Lisa Londo. “I don’t know.”
The Londos said they moved to the home on Aldus Drive with their four children because their previous apartment was filled with black mold.
“We really thought that we had found the right place,” Lisa Londo said.
The investigation into Bybel began when a real estate agent, also a part-time Pasco deputy, was recently trying to show a house that was for sale but discovered the locks had been changed. He saw a notice from Bybel’s company on the door and called him. Bybel told him he had “gotten the wrong house” and then provided a key to the Realtor, a sheriff’s office report states.
In September, Bybel started a company – Real T Solutions Investments, LLC — and hit the streets of central Pasco searching for vacant homes. He would select some and then by filing a one-paragraph “memorandum of adverse possession” legal notice with the Pasco Clerk of Courts office, he would take possession of such properties. Bybel would then change the homes’ locks, sometimes give them a fresh coat of interior paint and then rent them out.
Bybel, who lives at 22430 Stillwood Drive, said Wednesday that he went through hoops trying to locate owners of the homes. He sent them letters via the mail, tried to find them on Facebook and left notices on their properties’ front doors. Detectives say they don’t believe any of the homeowners were properly contacted.
One of the homes which Bybel has taken over, White said, is owned by another deputy who just started work this week.
Apparently, it’s a scheme that’s being done in Miami and Las Vegas, the sheriff said. In fact, White said, they are investigating another unrelated similar scheme in Pasco.
This comes at a time when tens of thousands of Florida homes are sitting empty, their owners too financially strapped to stay. Keeping track of so many homes is taxing on lenders, and many of the homes have been abandoned by owners waiting for foreclosure to be finalized.
It’s easy to see how foreclosed homes could slip through the cracks, said Anthony DiMarco, spokesman for the Florida Bankers Association. He said he hasn’t heard of such a scheme but isn’t surprised.
“There has been so much mortgage fraud, and there are lots of foreclosed homes,” he said. “It’s a matter of numbers.”
Bybel has maintained to authorities he was within his legal rights of adverse possession, said Detective Jeff Peake of the economic crimes unit.
The adverse possession statute’s intent, said White, is indeed to claim property but not in the way in which Bybel interpreted it. For example, he said, if someone mistakenly builds a structure that stretches over the property line of his neighbor’s and it goes uncontested for a certain amount of time, the land can be claimed as the person who built the building.
“That’s nowhere near this,” White said of what Bybel was doing. “This is closer to burglary and grand theft than adverse possession.”
Bybel said when he was setting up his business he ran the idea by a few lawyers.
“They all said this was a gray area,” he said. “They didn’t say not to do it.”
The way Bybel sees it, he cleaning up his community while helping others, kind of a modern day Robin Hood in times of an economy mired in recession. In fact, his company mission statement says as much.
“Help stabilize communities blighted by vacant homes. Clean up the properties and provide affordable housing to citizens in transition,” it states in part.
“I read the papers,” Bybel said. “I watch the news and the world is falling apart and nobody is doing nothing about it.”
Illegal or not, he said, he’s helping “save” Pasco.
“It’s a victimless crime,” he said.
Bybel said he wanted to make renting homes in this economy easier for people who have lost their homes, such as himself. His New Jersey home, he said, was foreclosed on about a year ago.
He advertised on Craigslist, didn’t collect deposits and didn’t charge outrageous monthly rents, Bybel said. All the while, he was making sure the homes were maintained and even did some repairs inside like patching walls, steam cleaning carpets and painting to make the homes nice for his renters – and the neighborhood.
Now those renters he says he helped – such as Londo — have to find new homes.
“They need to find a place to live and like they say, quick like a bunny,” White said.